Raedan Institute logo

The UK Cyber-Attack Crisis: Synnovis, M&S, Co-op and What They Tell Us About National Vulnerability

The UK Cyber-Attack Crisis: Synnovis, M&S, Co-op and What They Tell Us About National Vulnerability


On 3 June 2024, a ransomware attack by the Russia-linked Qilin group struck Synnovis — a pathology partnership providing laboratory services to Guy's and St Thomas' NHS Foundation Trust and King's College Hospital NHS Foundation Trust in London. Within days, over 800 planned operations and 700 outpatient appointments had been cancelled. Blood transfusion services were severely disrupted. The attack exposed with brutal clarity how deeply the NHS's clinical operations depend on digital infrastructure, and how catastrophic the consequences can be when that infrastructure fails (NHS England, 2024).

The Synnovis attack was not an isolated incident. It was the most clinically severe in a sustained wave of major cyber incidents affecting UK organisations across healthcare, retail, government and critical national infrastructure. In April and May 2025, Marks and Spencer and the Co-op Group both suffered significant cyber incidents that disrupted online operations, retail systems and supply chains over periods of weeks. The NCSC's Annual Review 2024 reported a record 89 nationally significant cyber incidents in the year — more than triple the previous year's figure (NCSC, 2024).


The Scale of the Threat

The UK Cyber Security Breaches Survey 2024 found that 50% of UK businesses had experienced a cyber attack in the previous twelve months, rising to 70% for large businesses (DSIT / Ipsos, 2024). The average annual cost of a cyber attack for any business was £1,205; for medium and large organisations, it was £10,830. IBM's Cost of a Data Breach Report 2024 put the global average breach cost at $4.88 million — a 10% increase year on year — with the UK average at $4.53 million (IBM, 2024).

These figures understate the true cost because they do not capture reputational damage, regulatory consequences, the long-term erosion of customer trust, or — in the NHS's case — the harm to patients caused by cancelled operations and disrupted clinical care. The estimated cost of the British Library ransomware attack in October 2023, which was conducted by the Rhysida group and took many months to recover from, was put at £6 to £7 million by the Library's own review — a figure representing a significant proportion of its annual budget (British Library, 2024).


Who Is Behind the Attacks?

Attribution in cyber security is complex and contested, but the NCSC and its Five Eyes partners have made increasingly specific public attributions of major attacks to state-linked and criminal groups. Russia-linked groups — including Sandworm, which is associated with Russian military intelligence (GRU), and criminal ransomware groups such as Qilin and Cl0p with alleged Russian ties — have been responsible for some of the highest-profile attacks on UK critical infrastructure.

China's Volt Typhoon group received a major public attribution from NCSC and its Five Eyes partners in February 2024. The group's activity, described in an advisory covering utilities, communications, transport and government systems, was characterised as pre-positioning for potential disruption rather than immediate theft — burrowing into critical infrastructure to enable future sabotage if geopolitical tensions escalated (NCSC, 2024b). This category of threat — persistent access maintained for future use — is in some ways more alarming than straightforward ransomware because it is designed to be invisible until it is activated.

North Korea's Lazarus Group specialises in cryptocurrency theft, having stolen billions of dollars in digital assets that fund the regime's weapons programmes. Iran's Charming Kitten group has targeted UK academic institutions, think tanks and journalists covering Iranian affairs. The threat landscape is genuinely multi-actor and multi-motivational, ranging from criminal ransomware operators seeking financial gain to state actors seeking intelligence, disruption or pre-positioned access.


Why the NHS Is Particularly Vulnerable

The NHS's vulnerability to cyber attacks reflects a combination of structural factors that are not unique to healthcare but are particularly pronounced within it. Legacy IT systems — software and hardware that may be decades old, no longer supported by their manufacturers and therefore unable to receive security patches — are widespread across NHS trusts. The decentralised nature of NHS IT, with hundreds of separate trusts each managing their own systems, creates an attack surface that is vast and difficult to defend consistently.

Investment in NHS cybersecurity has increased significantly following the WannaCry attack in 2017, which disrupted operations across 34 NHS trusts when the ransomware exploited vulnerabilities in unpatched Windows XP systems. But investment has consistently lagged behind the evolving threat landscape and the growing complexity of NHS digital infrastructure. The integration of third-party suppliers — pathology labs, imaging providers, community health systems — extends the attack surface beyond what any individual trust controls, as the Synnovis incident demonstrated with particular force.


What Organisations Must Do: The Baseline

The NCSC's Cyber Essentials framework — a government-backed scheme providing a baseline of technical controls — covers five key areas: firewalls, secure configuration, user access control, malware protection and patch management. Research consistently shows that implementing Cyber Essentials would mitigate the majority of common cyber attacks. The tragedy of the UK's cyber security landscape is not that the solutions are unknown — they are well documented — but that implementation is uneven, particularly among smaller organisations and across the fragmented public sector.

For the NHS specifically, the recommendations from multiple post-incident reviews converge on the same priorities: accelerated retirement of legacy systems, centralised procurement of security tooling with consistent implementation standards, mandatory Cyber Essentials Plus certification for all NHS suppliers, and investment in the cyber security workforce pipeline through apprenticeships and graduate schemes. These are not cheap or quick fixes. They require sustained political will and funding commitment across multiple spending reviews.

The cyber security challenge is ultimately a governance challenge as much as a technical one. The organisations that are most resilient to cyber attack are not necessarily those with the most sophisticated technical defences. They are those where leadership takes cybersecurity seriously, where security culture is embedded at every level, where incident response plans are tested and not merely filed, and where the relationship between security teams, operational teams and senior management is one of genuine collaboration rather than silos and blame.


References

  • British Library (2024) Cyber Incident Review: What Happened and What We Learned. London: British Library, March.
  • DSIT / Ipsos (2024) Cyber Security Breaches Survey 2024. London: Department for Science, Innovation and Technology.
  • IBM (2024) Cost of a Data Breach Report 2024. Armonk: IBM Security.
  • NCSC (2024) NCSC Annual Review 2024. London: National Cyber Security Centre, December.
  • NCSC (2024b) People's Republic of China State-Sponsored Cyber Actor Living off the Land to Evade Detection [Joint Advisory]. London: NCSC, February.
  • NHS England (2024) Synnovis Cyber Incident: NHS England Statement. London: NHS England, June.